"We have a small window to pay for the winter's bills," Robert "Okie" Whitcraft of Okie's Butcher Shop told The SandPaper in early October. He was explaining why a Surf City butcher would raise money for two Beach Haven storefronts he doesn't own.
This fall, Bay Avenue's businesses have run on the same rule as the island's volunteer fire companies. When one is in trouble, the others show up with equipment, keys, lunch or cash, and nobody keeps score. The calendar from now to the third week of December follows that pattern. It reaches its peak on Saturday, November 28, when Beach Haven Volunteer Fire Company No. 1 opens its doors at 100 S. Bay Ave. for Shop Small Saturday.
Seven in the Morning at 610 North Bay
The fire company got the call at about 7 a.m. on Wednesday, September 30. Smoke was already rising over 610 N. Bay Ave. when a deputy chief got close, and the response went to a second alarm, Jersey Shore Online reported. Crews fought the fire from outside while they secured a water source. When more firefighters arrived, they went in and put out most of it.
Beach Haven did not handle it alone. Companies from Ship Bottom, High Point, Stafford Township, Parkertown and Forked River came in to help, along with Beach Haven First Aid, Stafford Township EMS and Beach Haven police. No one was hurt.
Two businesses share that address. BLVD Pizza had opened its Beach Haven location only recently. In a statement on its Facebook page, quoted by Jersey Shore Online, the pizzeria said, "It'll be a long road, but we'll come back stronger," and said it would focus first on reopening its Surf City shop. Next door, the boutique Sincerely, June also had heavy damage. It thanked first responders and posted, "The support across this island is unparalleled & we don't take it for granted." Patch also covered the fire the afternoon it happened. Neither business has announced a reopening date. If you walk the north end of Bay Avenue this month, expect that corner to stay dark for a while.
The Same Rule, Applied Without Sirens
Mutual aid is written into how fire companies work. Before the fire, Bay Avenue's merchants had already spent a week showing they work the same way.
A nor'easter came in on Friday, September 25, and water was inside Barry's Do Me a Flavor by Saturday morning. Barry Baxter has owned the restaurant since 1987, and this is its 39th season. He told The SandPaper that water had reached the front of the building only three times. There were 16 inches in the '92 storm and 37 during Sandy. This time it was about 8. The kitchen was spared. The dining room and garage storage were not, and the ice cream parlor side was shut down just ahead of Chowder Cook-Off weekend.
Help came from both ends of the island. The Boardwalk ice cream shop in Holgate and Poppy's Ice Cream Parlour in Barnegat Light had both closed for the season, and both offered their equipment. Poppy's had the better fit. "Within five minutes, Lori was dropping off a key," Baxter told The SandPaper, meaning Lori Malay of Poppy's and How You Brewin. Barry's opened for the Cook-Off. Baxter's explanation is the closest thing Bay Avenue has to a written policy: "In July and August, there's plenty of business for all of us. It's not a competition."
Around the corner, Guapo's Coffee House took on a lot of water, and the cleanup lasted for days. Owner Sammy Jo Alvarez told The SandPaper that during the worst tides that weekend, "Nicole from Barry's was sending me updates pretty much hourly," and that "Matt from k+co LIVING bought all of us lunch on the first day of cleaning."
Then came the fire. Okie's Butcher Shop and the social media page LBI Source started a fundraiser for BLVD Pizza, Sincerely, June and their employees. By October 5, it had raised $29,194. Whitcraft tied it to a much older storm. "Since the storm of '62, we all helped each other then, and we should all help each other now." He also told The SandPaper that insurance "doesn't always cover a whole lot" these days.
A shop that usually stays open through Columbus Day lost part of its equipment two weeks before its last big weekend. A pizzeria that had only just opened its Beach Haven location lost it to fire before its first winter. The help covered the gap between a short season and a long off-season.
Getting Down Bay Avenue Right Now
Bay Avenue is also physically torn up. On October 22, the Borough of Beach Haven posted this construction update:
- Bay Avenue water and sewer main replacement. Crews work two blocks at a time. They started between 12th and 10th streets around October 19, with detours starting and ending one block on either side of the work. Southbound traffic goes to Delaware Avenue and northbound traffic goes to Atlantic Avenue.
- West Avenue between Engleside and Coral is closed for lateral work, which started September 21.
- Amber Street has lateral work on the 500 block.
- The Ocean County road project has curb and sidewalk work between Iroquois and Berkeley avenues, moving north. Drainage work continues between Norwood Avenue and Pearl Street.
Because the Bay Avenue crews move two blocks at a time, the work zone will probably have moved by the time you read this. Check the borough's homepage before you pick a route. The same page says the borough has lifted its beach closure, though some areas are still fenced off for safety. Use the entrances that are open.
Who Is Still Pouring Coffee
The detours matter more because the number of open places shrinks every week. Guapo's Coffee House, at 106 N. Bay Ave., lists its season on its own site as May 1 to January 1. That means its rooftop lounge and small-batch coffee should be available through the holidays, on the same north end of Bay Avenue as the fire-damaged block. Guapo's opened in 2023, so this is only its third season, and it spent days cleaning up after the nor'easter before heading into the stretch its own schedule says runs to New Year's.
Barry's tells a different story about timing. Baxter said the restaurant usually stays open through Columbus Day weekend, so its season has ended for the year whether or not the storm had hit. The loaned equipment kept it from losing those last weekends.
November 28 at 100 South Bay
Here is where the fall's pattern lands. Beach Haven Volunteer Fire Co. #1 is hosting Shop Small Saturday at its building at 100 S. Bay Ave. on November 28, 2026, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., according to the Ocean County Tourism listing. The listing says the only way to request a vendor spot is to email [email protected].
The company whose crews went into 610 N. Bay Ave. eight weeks earlier is now giving local sellers a room on the Saturday after Thanksgiving. Small businesses in a seasonal town have helped each other all fall, and on November 28 the firehouse gives them a place to sell at the start of the holiday season.
That afternoon, Surflight Theatre also opens its holiday run of Irving Berlin's Holiday Inn. The musical follows Jim, who leaves show business for a Connecticut farm and turns it into an inn that puts on a show for every holiday, with "White Christmas," "Blue Skies" and "Easter Parade" in the score. The schedule posted by Surflight:
- 2 p.m. matinees: Nov. 28 and 29; Dec. 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 13, 16, 17, 19 and 20
- 7:30 p.m. evenings: Nov. 28; Dec. 4, 5, 12, 18 and 19
With a 2 p.m. curtain on the 28th, you can go to the firehouse market in the morning and still make the matinee. The 7:30 p.m. show works if you'd rather keep the afternoon free. The week before, Surflight hosts Holidays with The Duprees on Sunday, November 22, from 2 to 4 p.m.
The borough's own events calendar also has an item marked for November 28. If you're planning the whole day, check the calendar as the date gets closer.
What happens with 610 N. Bay Ave. depends on BLVD Pizza and Sincerely, June, and neither has set a date. The block around it already has its schedule for the rest of the year. The county's curb work keeps moving north, Guapo's stays open until January 1, the firehouse opens to local vendors on November 28, and Holiday Inn plays its last matinee on December 20.
At Coastal Living Real Estate Group, Beach Haven is home base, and we keep track of how Bay Avenue changes after the season ends: which doors stay open, which blocks are closed, and which weekends bring people back into town. If you own a Beach Haven home and want to talk about how the off-season calendar affects your plans for it, we're glad to start with a complimentary coastal market evaluation.